Conservatives must confront antisemitism in their own ranks | Opinion

(Originally published in the Tennessean)

The Oldest Hatred is Growing Again, and Conservatives Must Confront It

Last year, as antisemitic protests swept across elite college campuses, I found myself having conversations I never imagined needing to have with my daughter. She is at that exciting stage of touring colleges, planning her next step, looking for a good fit and well-matched academics, and dreaming big. But instead of just talking about programs or professors, I had to talk about safety and which schools were tolerating hate masquerading as activism.

Columbia University and George Washington University stood out as particularly shameful examples. On those campuses, Jewish students were harassed, doxed, and shouted down, often while faculty and administrators looked the other way. At Columbia, antisemitic incidents nearly doubled last year, part of a broader national surge that saw 83% of Jewish students report firsthand experiences of antisemitism. I told my daughter plainly to stay away from any institution that excuses this kind of hate. That included GW, the place where her mother and I first met in graduate school, and a university she might have otherwise considered.

More recently, I have had to confront a different, uncomfortable truth. Antisemitism is no longer isolated to the radical leftists in academia and the fringes of society. Sadly, it has exploded on the right as well, especially online. As someone who has spent a career working to help elect conservative Republicans at all levels, this is gravely concerning to me.

The vile rhetoric that once festered on obscure online message boards has found new champions with large followings. For instance, Candace Owens, once a respected conservative voice, now aggressively echoes tropes that are unmistakably antisemitic, questioning the loyalty of Jewish Americans and implying that “globalist” Jewish elites manipulate world events. Owens claimed that Judaism was a “pedophile-centric religion that believes in demons…[and] child sacrifice …” She claims the Jews were behind 9/11. These are not innocent, isolated slips. They are deliberate appeals to resentment and division, and they are beyond disgusting.

And then there is Nick Fuentes, an avowed white-nationalist livestreamer who has repeatedly praised Adolf Hitler and openly celebrates Holocaust denial. On social media, he called Hitler “really f-ing cool.” He has fantasized about teaming up with Hitler to commit violence and urged followers to prepare “for war” against Jews. His rhetoric is not subtle or metaphorical—it is raw, vicious, and deeply antisemitic, and it is accelerating in reach and influence on the right. 

These hateful statements, made by individuals with a strong media presence and public following, give others the false idea that it is acceptable for them to do the same. As someone who has called out antisemitism on the left, I would be a hypocrite not to do the same when it rears its ugly head on the right. This poison does not belong to one party or one movement. It is the world’s oldest hatred, and it thrives wherever people are too cowardly to name it. 

The American Jewish community is increasingly anxious. Seventy-seven percent say they feel less safe since the Hamas attacks, and a third have personally experienced antisemitism in the past year. If we truly believe in moral clarity, it has to apply universally. We cannot demand accountability from one side and turn a blind eye to the other.

As a Christian and a lifelong conservative, I believe in personal responsibility and moral consistency. If we lose the courage to call out hate, no matter where it comes from, then we forfeit the moral high ground entirely. My principles do not change based on who is spreading the hatred, and neither should anyone else’s. 

Previous

Next

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *